Homer and Marge set sail on a second honeymoon, but they're interrupted by a castaway, whom they rescue. Roger was a chef on the Albatross who was knocked out after trying to prevent an attempted poisoning on the ship. Convinced that Roger poisoned the passengers and is plotting to murder them after seeing a dead shark with a recently made pie pan in its mouth, Homer and Marge take matters into their own hands as they seemingly kill Roger and knock his body overboard. However, finding the Albatross, they realize Roger was telling the truth. Roger appears again and Homer kills him, and the surviving bankers, shocking Marge, who eats the poisonous pie. It would all turn out to be Maggie's imagination. Homer soon asks what Maggie thinks and Marge replies that it's nice things. Soon Maggie sinisterly changes into Alex DeLarge whilst eerie music plays in the background as the screen goes dark.